Log in

No account? Create an account

Previous Entry | Next Entry

Jan. 15th, 2017

So, Sherlock.

I've been talking about this a bit over at Tumblr, but kept my thoughts sort of to myself over here. I have to say, so far I've been disappointed with this series. And a lot of that is boil-over from S3 disappointment of the type "I have bad feelings here but am withholding judgment until I see where they're going with this." The first two series will always be dear in my heart, and I love specific scenes from the last two series, S4 particularly. I just feel like the characterizations aren't there, that it's more about fizz-bang than telling a story that makes sense.

That's my impression through the first two episodes. I still haven't seen FIN, seeing it in the theaters tomorrow so holding off. And I'm trying very hard to ignore the wailing and gnashing of teeth coming from Tumblr, though I do have a very bad feeling here. Mainly it's come to be a fanworks delivery system more than a show, which is a nice universe to have, but not exactly a show succeeding in its primary function.

I've come a bit back to playing in the Tolkien sandbox, particularly the Silm corner of the fandom. One story that just needs a final coat os spit-polish, another I took an hour today to reread some canon and start outlining. I'd also like to write some Doyle fic but I really feel I don't know enough about Victorian times to do that well. I really want to, I just... I don't even know where to start there. I've been reading/re-reading the Doyle originals, and falling in love with them. So clever, so sweet, so much fun!


Jan. 16th, 2017 10:18 pm (UTC)
Parts of Tumblr are way overboard. But a lot of more mature fans I respect had problems with this episode from the little bit I've seen. This whole series didn't sit that well with me, it seemed so big it got a bit careless I think, and definitely not like the first two series I fell in love with.

However. Not seen the thing yet, and definitely don't want to prejudge or throw away this gift of actual canon. I really am going to try to forget all the criticism I've heard and take it on its own merits.



Latest Month

November 2019


Page Summary

Powered by LiveJournal.com
Designed by Tiffany Chow